Own-brand copy HP35A toner cartr (BR4 - West Wickham south side)

I was persuaded to buy a Cartridge People own-brand version of the Hewlett Packard 35a laserjet toner cartridge, but it didn't fit comfortably in my HP P1005 printer. They suggested I send it for recycling, but I thought I'd see first whether anyone else wanted to give it a try.
PLEASE NOTE: Although the Cartridge People have a policy of compensating you for any damage caused to your printer by their own-brand cartridges, this only applies to the original purchaser, so you WILL NOT be covered by it.

Fair Offer Policy applies